ISBN: 8185984131
Tagline: A process of ongoing improvement.
The Goal was not on my reading list. However, it was lying around in the house and I decided to go ahead with it. The size of this book was very uninviting and from all the text on the covers and in the intro pages, I thought that I’d be better off reading this book during or after my MBA even though it was a best-seller. However, once I started to read I realized that this whole “Theory of constraints” thing is actually presented in the form of a story which is very easy to grasp.
About the Author
Dr. Eliyahu M. Goldratt is an internationally recognized leader in the development of new business management concepts and systems, and acts as an educator to many of the world’s corporations. He is the originator of the Theory of Constraints (TOC) and his ideas have revolutionized the way companies work.
In addition to his pioneering work in manufacturing management, he holds patents in other areas, ranging from medical devices to temperature sensors. Other books from Goldratt, on this topic, are It’s Not Luck, Critical Chain and Necessary But Not Sufficient.
The Goal
Plainly speaking The Goal is a book on Theory of Constraints. However along with the message, another important side to this book is the method the author has adopted to deliver the message. The Goal is actually the story (probably fictitious) of a plant manager by name Alex Rogo who manages a plant that is unable to ship any of its orders on time and is also losing money for its division. In addition, Alex has a messed-up personal life due to frequent fights with his wife.
Alex is given a deadline to make the plant profitable (failing which it will be closed). He desperately wants to save his plant and in the process he meets his university professor and acquaintance (from college days), Jonah (which I think is characterizing Goldratt because both have a degree in Physics from Israel). Alex’s interactions with Jonah show him the right path. Jonah is a kind of teacher who encourages his students to discover answers on their own and he does the same with Alex (regarding the problem with his plant). Through Alex’s process of discovery the author explains the theory of constraints in a very simple manner. I was particularly impressed by the use of a simple yet powerful example of boys marching in a line. The author through Alex’s discussions with his co-workers also highlights the short comings of cost-accounting where inventory is viewed as an asset on the balance sheet and the blind emphasis of management to cut costs wherever possible (which many times leads to death of sick business units that could have been turned around).
Conclusion
Services have become the fad of today and it is amazing to think about the application of TOC to the Services scenario (though I need to grow-up a little more to think about it in detail). With the advent of Globalization 3.0 (in terms of Thomas Friedman) and the ability of a business to break up a process, digitize it and outsource it to various parts of the world where they can be done (for cheapest price and best quality) simultaneously and delivered back in one piece to the HQ control, the relevance of this theory is questionable. However, I am sure that it still has a lot of implications on supply chains where constraints or bottlenecks may exist (again I need to learn a lot more to think in detail).
In one of the management fests I had participated in during my college days, I had taken part in a production game where there was a production line with different work centers. The performance of the participants was measured in terms of their ability to meet customer demands and have least inventories and turn-around times at the end of the game. Had I read this book back then, before that event, I am sure I would have done much better than the third spot out of fifth that I had got in that event.
The Goal – ఎలియాహు ఎం. గోల్డ్రాట్ (Eliyahu M. Goldratt), జెఫ్ కాక్స్ (Jeff Cox) (పుస్తక సమీక్ష 009)
ISBN: 8185984131
ట్యాగ్లైన్: నిరంతర మెరుగుదల ప్రక్రియ.
The Goal నా పఠన జాబితాలో లేదు. అయితే ఇంట్లో అది పడి ఉండటంతో చదివి చూద్దామని నిర్ణయించుకున్నాను. పుస్తకం పరిమాణం అస్సలు ఆకర్షణీయంగా లేదు, కవర్లపై, పరిచయ పేజీల్లో ఉన్న రాతను చూసి, ఇది బెస్ట్ సెల్లర్ అయినా నా MBA సమయంలో లేదా తర్వాత చదివితే బాగుంటుందనిపించింది. కానీ చదవడం మొదలుపెట్టాక, ఈ “థియరీ ఆఫ్ కాన్స్ట్రెయింట్స్” అంతా ఒక కథ రూపంలో చెప్పబడిందని, అందువల్ల చాలా సులభంగా అర్థమవుతుందని గ్రహించాను.
రచయిత గురించి
డాక్టర్ ఎలియాహు ఎం. గోల్డ్రాట్ కొత్త వ్యాపార నిర్వహణ భావనలు, వ్యవస్థల అభివృద్ధిలో అంతర్జాతీయంగా గుర్తింపు పొందిన నాయకుడు, అనేక ప్రపంచ కార్పొరేషన్లకు విద్యావేత్తగా వ్యవహరిస్తున్నారు. ఆయన థియరీ ఆఫ్ కాన్స్ట్రెయింట్స్ (TOC) సృష్టికర్త, ఆయన ఆలోచనలు కంపెనీలు పనిచేసే విధానాన్ని విప్లవాత్మకంగా మార్చాయి.
తయారీ నిర్వహణలో ఆయన చేసిన మార్గదర్శక కృషితో పాటు, వైద్య పరికరాల నుంచి ఉష్ణోగ్రత సెన్సార్ల వరకు ఇతర రంగాల్లో కూడా ఆయనకు పేటెంట్లు ఉన్నాయి. ఈ అంశంపై గోల్డ్రాట్ రాసిన ఇతర పుస్తకాలు It’s Not Luck, Critical Chain, Necessary But Not Sufficient.
The Goal
సూటిగా చెప్పాలంటే, The Goal థియరీ ఆఫ్ కాన్స్ట్రెయింట్స్ గురించిన పుస్తకం. అయితే సందేశంతో పాటు, ఆ సందేశాన్ని అందించడానికి రచయిత ఎంచుకున్న పద్ధతి కూడా ఈ పుస్తకంలోని మరో ముఖ్యమైన కోణం. The Goal నిజానికి అలెక్స్ రోగో (Alex Rogo) అనే ప్లాంట్ మేనేజర్ కథ (బహుశా కల్పితం). అతను నడిపే ప్లాంట్ ఏ ఆర్డర్నూ సమయానికి పంపించలేకపోతోంది, తన విభాగానికి నష్టాలు కూడా తెస్తోంది. దీనికి తోడు, భార్యతో తరచూ జరిగే గొడవల వల్ల అలెక్స్ వ్యక్తిగత జీవితం కూడా అస్తవ్యస్తంగా ఉంది.
ప్లాంట్ను లాభదాయకంగా మార్చడానికి అలెక్స్కు ఒక గడువు ఇస్తారు (లేకపోతే దాన్ని మూసివేస్తారు). అతను తన ప్లాంట్ను కాపాడుకోవాలని తీవ్రంగా కోరుకుంటాడు, ఆ ప్రయత్నంలో తన విశ్వవిద్యాలయ ప్రొఫెసర్, కాలేజీ రోజుల నుంచి పరిచయస్తుడైన జోనాను (Jonah) కలుస్తాడు (గోల్డ్రాట్ను ప్రతిబింబించే పాత్ర అని నా అభిప్రాయం, ఎందుకంటే ఇద్దరూ ఇజ్రాయెల్ నుంచి ఫిజిక్స్లో డిగ్రీ చేసినవారు). జోనాతో అలెక్స్ చర్చలు అతనికి సరైన దారి చూపిస్తాయి. జోనా తన విద్యార్థులు జవాబులను వారే కనుగొనేలా ప్రోత్సహించే ఒక రకమైన గురువు, అలెక్స్ విషయంలో (అతని ప్లాంట్ సమస్య గురించి) కూడా అదే చేస్తాడు. అలెక్స్ కనుగొనే ప్రక్రియ ద్వారా రచయిత థియరీ ఆఫ్ కాన్స్ట్రెయింట్స్ను చాలా సరళంగా వివరిస్తారు. వరుసలో కవాతు చేసే అబ్బాయిల సరళమైన, అయినా శక్తివంతమైన ఉదాహరణ నన్ను ప్రత్యేకంగా ఆకట్టుకుంది. అలెక్స్ తన సహోద్యోగులతో జరిపే చర్చల ద్వారా, ఇన్వెంటరీని బ్యాలెన్స్ షీట్లో ఆస్తిగా చూసే కాస్ట్-అకౌంటింగ్ లోపాలను, వీలైన చోటల్లా ఖర్చులు తగ్గించాలనే యాజమాన్యాల గుడ్డి పట్టుదలను కూడా రచయిత చూపిస్తారు (ఇది చాలాసార్లు, తిరిగి గాడిలో పెట్టగలిగిన అనారోగ్య వ్యాపార విభాగాల మరణానికి దారితీస్తుంది).
ముగింపు
ఈ రోజుల్లో సేవా రంగం ఒక వ్యామోహంగా మారింది, సేవల పరిస్థితికి TOCని అన్వయించడం గురించి ఆలోచిస్తే ఆశ్చర్యంగా ఉంది (అయితే దాన్ని వివరంగా ఆలోచించడానికి నేను ఇంకొంచెం ఎదగాలి). థామస్ ఫ్రీడ్మన్ (Thomas Friedman) మాటల్లో గ్లోబలైజేషన్ 3.0 రాకతో, ఒక ప్రక్రియను విడగొట్టి, డిజిటైజ్ చేసి, ప్రపంచంలో ఎక్కడ (తక్కువ ధరకు, ఉత్తమ నాణ్యతతో) చేయించుకోవచ్చో అక్కడ ఏకకాలంలో చేయించి, తిరిగి ప్రధాన కార్యాలయ నియంత్రణలో ఒకే ముక్కగా అందుకునే సామర్థ్యం వ్యాపారానికి వచ్చాక, ఈ సిద్ధాంతం ఎంతవరకు ప్రాసంగికమనేది ప్రశ్నార్థకం. అయినా, పరిమితులు లేదా అడ్డంకులు ఉండగల సరఫరా గొలుసుల (supply chains) విషయంలో దీనికి ఇంకా చాలా ప్రభావాలు ఉన్నాయని నాకు నమ్మకం ఉంది (దీని గురించి కూడా వివరంగా ఆలోచించడానికి నేను ఇంకా చాలా నేర్చుకోవాలి).
నా కాలేజీ రోజుల్లో నేను పాల్గొన్న ఒక మేనేజ్మెంట్ ఫెస్ట్లో ఒక ప్రొడక్షన్ గేమ్లో పాల్గొన్నాను; అందులో వేర్వేరు వర్క్ సెంటర్లతో ఒక ఉత్పత్తి లైన్ ఉండేది. కస్టమర్ డిమాండ్లను తీర్చే సామర్థ్యం, ఆట చివరిలో తక్కువ ఇన్వెంటరీలు, తక్కువ టర్న్అరౌండ్ సమయాలు ఆధారంగా పాల్గొనేవారి పనితీరును కొలిచేవారు. ఆ కార్యక్రమానికి ముందే ఈ పుస్తకం చదివి ఉంటే, ఐదుగురిలో మూడో స్థానం కంటే చాలా మెరుగ్గా చేసేవాడినని నాకు ఖచ్చితంగా తెలుసు.
The Goal: एलियाहू एम. गोल्डरैट (Eliyahu M. Goldratt) और जेफ़ कॉक्स (Jeff Cox) (पुस्तक समीक्षा 009)
ISBN: 8185984131
टैगलाइन: निरंतर सुधार की एक प्रक्रिया।
The Goal मेरी पढ़ने की सूची में नहीं थी। लेकिन यह घर में पड़ी थी और मैंने इसे पढ़ने का मन बना लिया। किताब का आकार बिल्कुल आकर्षक नहीं था, और कवर तथा शुरुआती पन्नों की सारी इबारत देखकर मुझे लगा कि बेस्ट-सेलर होने के बावजूद इसे MBA के दौरान या उसके बाद पढ़ना ही ठीक रहेगा। लेकिन पढ़ना शुरू करते ही समझ आया कि यह पूरा “थ्योरी ऑफ़ कंस्ट्रेंट्स” दरअसल एक कहानी के रूप में पेश किया गया है, जो बहुत आसानी से समझ में आती है।
लेखक के बारे में
डॉ. एलियाहू एम. गोल्डरैट (Eliyahu M. Goldratt) नए व्यावसायिक प्रबंधन विचारों और प्रणालियों के विकास में अंतरराष्ट्रीय स्तर पर मान्य अग्रणी हैं और दुनिया की कई कंपनियों के लिए शिक्षक की भूमिका निभाते हैं। वे थ्योरी ऑफ़ कंस्ट्रेंट्स (TOC) के जनक हैं और उनके विचारों ने कंपनियों के काम करने का तरीका बदल दिया है।
विनिर्माण प्रबंधन में अपने अग्रणी काम के अलावा उनके पास चिकित्सा उपकरणों से लेकर तापमान सेंसरों तक, दूसरे क्षेत्रों में भी पेटेंट हैं। इस विषय पर गोल्डरैट की अन्य पुस्तकें हैं It’s Not Luck, Critical Chain और Necessary But Not Sufficient।
The Goal
सीधे शब्दों में कहूँ तो The Goal थ्योरी ऑफ़ कंस्ट्रेंट्स पर लिखी किताब है। लेकिन संदेश के साथ-साथ इस किताब का एक और अहम पहलू वह तरीका है जो लेखक ने संदेश पहुँचाने के लिए अपनाया है। The Goal दरअसल एक प्लांट मैनेजर की कहानी है (शायद काल्पनिक), जिसका नाम एलेक्स रोगो (Alex Rogo) है। उसका प्लांट अपना कोई भी ऑर्डर समय पर नहीं भेज पाता और अपने डिवीज़न को घाटे में भी डाल रहा है। ऊपर से पत्नी से बार-बार झगड़ों के कारण एलेक्स की निजी ज़िंदगी भी उलझी हुई है।
एलेक्स को प्लांट को मुनाफ़े में लाने की एक समयसीमा दी जाती है (जिसमें नाकाम रहने पर प्लांट बंद कर दिया जाएगा)। वह अपने प्लांट को बचाने के लिए बेताब है और इसी दौरान उसकी मुलाक़ात अपने विश्वविद्यालय के प्रोफ़ेसर और कॉलेज के दिनों के परिचित जोना (Jonah) से होती है (जिसे मैं गोल्डरैट का ही रूप मानता हूँ, क्योंकि दोनों के पास इज़राइल से भौतिकी की डिग्री है)। जोना से एलेक्स की बातचीत उसे सही राह दिखाती है। जोना एक ऐसे शिक्षक की तरह है जो अपने छात्रों को जवाब खुद खोजने के लिए प्रेरित करता है, और एलेक्स के साथ (उसके प्लांट की समस्या को लेकर) वह यही करता है। एलेक्स की खोज की इस प्रक्रिया के ज़रिये लेखक थ्योरी ऑफ़ कंस्ट्रेंट्स को बहुत सरल ढंग से समझाते हैं। मैं ख़ासतौर पर कतार में चलते लड़कों के सरल पर असरदार उदाहरण से प्रभावित हुआ। एलेक्स की अपने सहकर्मियों से चर्चाओं के ज़रिये लेखक कॉस्ट-अकाउंटिंग की कमियों को भी उजागर करते हैं, जिसमें इन्वेंट्री को बैलेंस शीट पर संपत्ति माना जाता है, और प्रबंधन के उस अंधे आग्रह को भी जो हर जगह लागत घटाने पर अड़ा रहता है (जो कई बार उन बीमार व्यावसायिक इकाइयों की मौत का कारण बनता है जिन्हें फिर से खड़ा किया जा सकता था)।
निष्कर्ष
आज सेवाएँ एक चलन बन गई हैं, और सेवा क्षेत्र में TOC के प्रयोग के बारे में सोचना दिलचस्प है (हालाँकि इस पर विस्तार से सोचने के लिए मुझे थोड़ा और परिपक्व होना पड़ेगा)। ग्लोबलाइज़ेशन 3.0 (थॉमस फ्रीडमैन (Thomas Friedman) के शब्दों में) के आने और किसी कारोबार के प्रक्रिया को तोड़कर, डिजिटल बनाकर और दुनिया के उन हिस्सों में आउटसोर्स करने की क्षमता के साथ, जहाँ वह (सबसे सस्ते दाम और सबसे अच्छी गुणवत्ता पर) एक साथ हो सकती है और फिर एक ही टुकड़े में मुख्यालय के नियंत्रण में लौट आती है, इस सिद्धांत की प्रासंगिकता पर सवाल उठता है। फिर भी मुझे यक़ीन है कि सप्लाई चेन में, जहाँ बाधाएँ या अड़चनें हो सकती हैं, इसके अब भी बहुत मायने हैं (इस बारे में भी मुझे बहुत कुछ सीखना बाक़ी है, ताकि विस्तार से सोच सकूँ)।
कॉलेज के दिनों में एक मैनेजमेंट फ़ेस्ट में मैंने एक प्रोडक्शन गेम में हिस्सा लिया था, जिसमें अलग-अलग वर्क सेंटरों वाली एक उत्पादन लाइन थी। प्रतिभागियों का प्रदर्शन इस आधार पर आँका गया कि वे ग्राहकों की माँग कितनी पूरी कर पाए और खेल के अंत में उनके पास सबसे कम इन्वेंट्री और सबसे कम टर्न-अराउंड समय कितना रहा। अगर मैंने उस आयोजन से पहले यह किताब पढ़ी होती, तो मुझे पक्का यक़ीन है कि मैं उस प्रतियोगिता में पाँच में से तीसरे स्थान से कहीं बेहतर कर पाता।
The Goal โดย Eliyahu M. Goldratt และ Jeff Cox (รีวิวหนังสือ 009)
ISBN: 8185984131
แท็กไลน์: กระบวนการปรับปรุงอย่างต่อเนื่อง
The Goal ไม่ได้อยู่ในรายการหนังสือที่ผมตั้งใจจะอ่าน แต่หนังสือเล่มนี้วางอยู่ในบ้าน ผมเลยตัดสินใจหยิบมาอ่าน ขนาดของเล่มดูไม่น่าอ่านเลย และจากข้อความทั้งหมดบนปกและในหน้าแนะนำ ผมคิดว่าน่าจะอ่านเล่มนี้ตอนเรียนหรือหลังเรียน MBA ดีกว่า แม้มันจะเป็นหนังสือขายดีก็ตาม แต่พอเริ่มอ่านก็พบว่า “ทฤษฎีข้อจำกัด” (Theory of constraints) ทั้งหมดนี้ถูกนำเสนอในรูปแบบเรื่องเล่า ซึ่งเข้าใจง่ายมาก
เกี่ยวกับผู้เขียน
ดร.เอลิยาฮู เอ็ม. โกลด์แรตต์ (Eliyahu M. Goldratt) เป็นผู้นำที่ได้รับการยอมรับในระดับนานาชาติด้านการพัฒนาแนวคิดและระบบการบริหารธุรกิจใหม่ ๆ และเป็นผู้ให้ความรู้แก่บริษัทใหญ่ ๆ จำนวนมากทั่วโลก เขาเป็นผู้ให้กำเนิดทฤษฎีข้อจำกัด (Theory of Constraints หรือ TOC) และแนวคิดของเขาปฏิวัติวิธีการทำงานของบริษัทต่าง ๆ
นอกจากงานบุกเบิกด้านการบริหารการผลิตแล้ว เขายังถือสิทธิบัตรในด้านอื่น ๆ ตั้งแต่อุปกรณ์การแพทย์ไปจนถึงเซนเซอร์วัดอุณหภูมิ หนังสือเล่มอื่นของโกลด์แรตต์ในหัวข้อเดียวกันนี้ ได้แก่ It’s Not Luck, Critical Chain และ Necessary But Not Sufficient
The Goal
พูดกันตรง ๆ The Goal คือหนังสือว่าด้วยทฤษฎีข้อจำกัด แต่นอกจากสาระที่ต้องการสื่อแล้ว อีกด้านสำคัญของหนังสือเล่มนี้คือวิธีที่ผู้เขียนเลือกใช้ในการสื่อสาร The Goal เป็นเรื่องราว (ซึ่งน่าจะเป็นเรื่องแต่ง) ของผู้จัดการโรงงานชื่ออเล็กซ์ โรโก (Alex Rogo) ซึ่งดูแลโรงงานที่ส่งคำสั่งซื้อไม่ทันกำหนดสักรายการ และทำให้แผนกของบริษัทขาดทุนด้วย ยิ่งกว่านั้น ชีวิตส่วนตัวของอเล็กซ์ก็ยุ่งเหยิงเพราะทะเลาะกับภรรยาบ่อย ๆ
อเล็กซ์ถูกกำหนดเส้นตายให้ทำให้โรงงานมีกำไร (ไม่เช่นนั้นจะถูกปิด) เขาอยากรักษาโรงงานไว้อย่างสุดชีวิต และระหว่างนั้นเขาได้พบกับศาสตราจารย์สมัยมหาวิทยาลัยและคนรู้จักจากสมัยเรียน คือโจนาห์ (Jonah) ซึ่งผมคิดว่าเป็นตัวแทนของโกลด์แรตต์ เพราะทั้งคู่จบปริญญาฟิสิกส์จากอิสราเอล การพูดคุยของอเล็กซ์กับโจนาห์ชี้ทางที่ถูกให้เขา โจนาห์เป็นครูประเภทที่ส่งเสริมให้ลูกศิษย์ค้นหาคำตอบด้วยตนเอง และเขาก็ทำเช่นเดียวกันกับอเล็กซ์ (เรื่องปัญหาของโรงงานเขา) ผ่านกระบวนการค้นพบของอเล็กซ์ ผู้เขียนอธิบายทฤษฎีข้อจำกัดอย่างเรียบง่ายมาก ผมประทับใจเป็นพิเศษกับการใช้ตัวอย่างที่เรียบง่ายแต่ทรงพลังเรื่องเด็กชายเดินแถว นอกจากนี้ ผู้เขียนผ่านบทสนทนาของอเล็กซ์กับเพื่อนร่วมงานยังชี้ให้เห็นข้อบกพร่องของการบัญชีต้นทุน ที่มองสินค้าคงคลังเป็นสินทรัพย์ในงบดุล และการที่ฝ่ายบริหารเน้นการตัดต้นทุนทุกทางอย่างมืดบอด (ซึ่งหลายครั้งนำไปสู่ความตายของหน่วยธุรกิจที่ป่วยแต่ยังกอบกู้ได้)
บทสรุป
ธุรกิจบริการกลายเป็นกระแสนิยมของยุคนี้ และน่าทึ่งที่ได้คิดถึงการประยุกต์ TOC กับสถานการณ์ของธุรกิจบริการ (แม้ผมต้องเติบโตอีกหน่อยจึงจะคิดอย่างละเอียดได้) เมื่อโลกาภิวัตน์ 3.0 (ตามที่โทมัส ฟรีดแมน (Thomas Friedman) เรียก) เข้ามา และธุรกิจสามารถแยกกระบวนการออกเป็นส่วน ๆ แปลงเป็นดิจิทัล แล้วจ้างทำนอกองค์กรในส่วนต่าง ๆ ของโลกที่ทำได้ (ในราคาถูกที่สุดและคุณภาพดีที่สุด) พร้อมกัน แล้วส่งกลับมารวมเป็นชิ้นเดียวภายใต้การควบคุมของสำนักงานใหญ่ ความเกี่ยวข้องของทฤษฎีนี้จึงน่าสงสัย อย่างไรก็ตาม ผมมั่นใจว่าทฤษฎีนี้ยังมีนัยสำคัญมากต่อห่วงโซ่อุปทานที่อาจมีข้อจำกัดหรือคอขวดอยู่ (อีกครั้ง ผมต้องเรียนรู้อีกมากจึงจะคิดอย่างละเอียดได้)
ในงานจัดกิจกรรมด้านการจัดการงานหนึ่งที่ผมเคยเข้าร่วมสมัยเรียนมหาวิทยาลัย ผมเข้าแข่งขันเกมการผลิต ซึ่งมีสายการผลิตที่มีศูนย์งานต่าง ๆ ผลงานของผู้เข้าร่วมวัดจากความสามารถในการตอบสนองความต้องการของลูกค้า และการมีสินค้าคงคลังกับเวลาดำเนินการน้อยที่สุดเมื่อจบเกม ถ้าผมได้อ่านหนังสือเล่มนี้ก่อนงานนั้น ผมมั่นใจว่าจะทำได้ดีกว่าอันดับสามจากห้าทีมที่ผมได้ในงานนั้นมาก